I've been playing around with where to start the story, and it seems to have dropped firmly into the realm of fantasy. I was playing out how to have O'Malley find out about the fatal fall Daniel-- his former lover-- took, and suddenly a little black critter ran up to O'Malley and huddled against him all upset about something (it was like a flying squirrel but not quite.) Apparently only O'Malley, and Daniel can see them. (Later, when Sean Brennan (Tobey Maguire's character), who looks like Daniel) comes to the monastery, he also had the ability to see them.) Well, that lead to having the Wild Hunt passing over Ireland at the beginning of the 'year of the slaughter'-- the Irish Famine of 1740-1741-- and I figure O'Malley will also be able to hear the banshees during the Famine.
I also discovered that there were priest hunters in Ireland during the time of the Penal Laws in Ireland. Found this on Wikipedia--
A Priest hunter was a person who, acting on behalf of British forces, spied on or captured Catholic priests during Penal Times in seventeenth and eighteenth century Ireland. A 1709 Penal Act demanded that catholic priests take the Oath of Abjuration, and recognise the Protestant Queen Anne as Queen of England, and by implication, Ireland. Priests that did not conform were arrested and executed. This activity, along with the deportation of priests who did conform, was a documented attempt to let the catholic clergy die out in Ireland within a generation. Priests had to register with the local magistrates to be allowed to preach, and most did so. Bishops were not able to register.
Priest hunters were effectively bounty hunters, and despite some opportunists, in most cases the men were criminals who were arrested and forced into the position by their police force. The reward rates for capture varied from £100-£50 for a Bishop, to £20-£10 for the capture of an unregistered priest; substantial amounts of money at the time. The work was dangerous, and some priests killed in defence. The men were outcast from their communities, and were viewed as the most despised class. Often when a gentleman informed on a priest, locals would effect revenge by burning his house and farmyard. The Penal law made fugitives of the remaining clerics, and they were forced to conduct ceremonies in secret, and in remote locations. Night time worship at mass rocks became common, although the attending priest would usually wear a veil, so that if an attendee was questioned they were able to truthfully say that they did not know who had said the Mass.
I'm thinking the bad guy in the story will be a priest hunter-- just to make poor O'Malley's life especially miserable. The hard part now is how to write O'Malley under the conditions the Catholic clergy lived with in the 18th century. (I'm not paying too much attention to accuracy in the rough draft, but would like to avoid having to rewrite major portions of it.)